| Platinum | Luigi's Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | Genova Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | Rapid Fired Pizza |
| Bronze | Stone Oven Gourmet Pizza & Eatery |
| Top Pick | Broad St. Billiards |
| Top Pick | Chuck E. Cheese's |
| Top Pick | Firo Fire Kissed Pizza |
| Top Pick | Half Pint Taproom & Restoration Hall |
| Top Pick | Mias Italian Bistro |
| Top Pick | Progress Pizza |