| Platinum | Fefe's Funnel Cakes |
| Platinum | Margies Sweet Shop & Deli |
| Gold | Cups & Cakes Bakery |
| Silver | Holly Cookie Co |
| Bronze | 1889 Cake & Coffee Bar |
| Top Pick | Cakes by Carolyn |
| Top Pick | Circle M Bakery |
| Top Pick | Dough Daddy |
| Top Pick | Market Street Bakery |
| Top Pick | Sam's Club |