| Platinum | Bill's Catfish in Waurika |
| Gold | Bradford's Fish Haus |
| Silver | Long John Silver's |
| Bronze | The Parkway Grill |
| Top Pick | Catfish Grill |
| Top Pick | McBrides Land & Cattle Co |
| Top Pick | Pelican's |
| Top Pick | Red Lobster |
| Top Pick | The Catch |
| Top Pick | Wasabi Japanese Steak House |