| Platinum | Bill's Catfish in Waurika |
| Platinum | Pelican's |
| Gold | The Crawfish Cowboy |
| Silver | Red Lobster |
| Bronze | Snookies Craft Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Barbarita's Restaurant Bar |
| Top Pick | Bradford's Fish Haus |
| Top Pick | Catfish Grill |
| Top Pick | Crab Kingdom |
| Top Pick | Fox Hill Restaurant |